36 notes November 16, 2012 Filed under Nostalgia Critic critic gif other special: Suburban Knights annoyed creator: whatsapaladin
92 notes November 13, 2012 Filed under Nostalgia Critic critic phelous angry annoyed gif gifset creator: whatsapaladin special: Suburban Knights
104 notes November 13, 2012 Filed under Nostalgia Critic critic angry gif annoyed frustrated creator: whatsapaladin special: Suburban Knights
83 notes November 5, 2012 (Source: seekeroftruth27) Filed under critic nostalgia critic gif gifset review: Casper creator: cpfoa27 timing other annoyed
29 notes October 21, 2012 Filed under creator: danzku review: Independence Day Nostalgia Critic Critic annoyed hand motions other gif
28 notes October 3, 2012 Filed under creator: danzku review: Titanic - The Legend Goes On Nostalgia Critic Critic screaming sarcasm annoyed other gif
25 notes October 1, 2012 Filed under Film Brain gif text creator: zhuzhka annoyed rage angry review: unknown (for now) submission
48 notes September 30, 2012 Filed under Oancitizen Kyle Kallgren 90's Kid Brows Held High gif review: The Doom Generation annoyed annoying facepalm creator: geekmuffins
49 notes September 24, 2012 Filed under creator: danzku review: Fullmetal Alchemist JesuOtaku Anime Review oancitizen annoyed angry threat gif
15 notes September 24, 2012 Filed under Critic Nostalgia Critic review: Mr. Magoo gif creator: whatsapaladin angry annoyed DAAH hand motions
